Travis Kelce is staying hush about his time in the kitchen with Taylor Swift.

During a press conference on Tuesday, June 11, the Kansas City Chiefs player dodged a question about cooking with his girlfriend. “There’s a YouTube Short of you cooking with your significant other, and I just kinda want to know what you like cooking together?” asked a reporter.

“That’s a good question,” Kelce said. “I respect that question but I’m going to keep that one to myself because I thoroughly enjoy cooking with her so it’s something I’d rather just keep personal.”

He moved on to the next question, but made one last comment on the topic before exiting.

“Taylor makes a great pop-tart and cinnamon roll,” the football player added with a cheeky smile.

A video of his answers was shared by a fan page, who referred to his final comments as a “mic drop moment.”

Fans in the comments praised Kelce for his witty response writing, “I find this very endearing” and “This is who Taylor deserves.”

Another fan asked Swift to release a cookbook so they could bake her “yummy” recipes.

In April, Swift shared a video on YouTube Shots of Kelce kissing her while she stirred a pot in a kitchen, along with other snapshots into her life, including one that showed her spreading whipped frosting on a batch of cinnamon rolls.

The PEOPLE Puzzler crossword is here! How quickly can you solve it? Play now!

She wrote on the video, “For a Fortnight…” in reference to the single from her latest album, The Tortured Poets Department.

Since Kelce and Swift went public with their romance in October 2023, the singer has baked for some of Kelce’s teammates.

“Kind of behind-the-scenes, she, to fit in — she didn’t even know she was doing this, I don’t think — she likes to cook, so she made the offensive linemen these homemade pop tarts,” recalled Kansas City Chiefs coach Andy Reid during an interview at the NFL Scouting Combine in February.

Earlier this month, Travis spoke with ABC’s Good Morning America about staying grounded amid his highly-publicized relationship and new career ventures.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

“When you have good family and friends around you, it makes that aspect in life that much easier,” Kelce said.

“I’ve always been a very grounded guy,” he added. “It might not come off like that when I’m playing football but off the field, I just want to be a genuine person. I try not to get too far down the road because you just never know when opportunities are going to present themselves.”